Butter Chicken, Chicken Tikka Masala or Chicken Korma? How to Pick a Mild Curry at New Kathmandu Kitchen on J Street in Sacramento

Three creamy chicken curries sit next to each other on most Indian menus, and they are easy to mix up when you are ordering for someone who doesn’t want a lot of heat. New Kathmandu Kitchen on J Street in East Sacramento cooks all three, and its ordering page describes each one in plain words, so you can choose by sauce, by cut of chicken and by what you need to avoid. This guide walks through what goes into Butter Chicken, Chicken Tikka Masala and Chicken Korma, which sides to add, and how to order the meal direct from the restaurant.

The three curries side by side

All three use boneless chicken in a thick, creamy sauce, and none of them carries the spicy label that the ordering page puts on its vindaloo dishes. The differences are in the sauce base and the cut of meat.

Curry What the menu says Chicken GF tag on the menu
Butter Chicken (GF) Tandoori chicken cooked in a thick buttery masala sauce Dark meat Yes
Chicken Tikka Masala Chicken cooked in a thick creamy onion-tomato masala sauce White meat No
Chicken Korma (GF) Chicken cooked in ginger, garlic and cashew with a creamy sauce Dark meat Yes

If you only remember one thing: Butter Chicken starts on the tandoor, Tikka Masala is the white-meat option, and Korma is the one built on cashew.

Butter Chicken: tandoori chicken in a buttery sauce

The menu describes Butter Chicken (GF) as tandoori boneless chicken, dark meat, cooked in a thick buttery masala sauce. The chicken is cooked in the tandoor first and then finished in the sauce, so this is the one to pick if you like the idea of tandoori chicken in a rich curry.

Order the Butter Chicken (GF) if:

  • You like a rich, buttery sauce that is easy to scoop up with naan.
  • Someone at the table prefers dark meat.
  • You want a curry that carries the GF tag on the ordering page.

Menu card — Butter Chicken (GF)

Tandoori boneless chicken (dark meat) cooked in a thick buttery masala sauce. Marked GF on the menu.

Order on the New Kathmandu Kitchen menu →

Chicken Tikka Masala: the white-meat choice

Chicken Tikka Masala is boneless white-meat chicken cooked in a thick, creamy onion-tomato masala sauce. The onion-tomato masala is the base here, where the Butter Chicken leans on a buttery masala. It is the pick for people who always order chicken breast.

One thing to know: on the ordering page, Chicken Tikka Masala does not carry the GF tag that the other two curries in this guide have. If you are ordering for someone who avoids gluten, choose the Butter Chicken or the Korma, or ask the kitchen about the Tikka Masala before you order.

Order the Chicken Tikka Masala if:

  • You prefer white-meat chicken.
  • You like an onion-tomato masala sauce more than a butter sauce.
  • No one in the group needs a gluten-free curry.

Menu card — Chicken Tikka Masala

Boneless chicken (white meat) cooked in a thick creamy onion-tomato masala sauce.

Order on the New Kathmandu Kitchen menu →

Chicken Korma: cashew and a creamy sauce

Chicken Korma (GF) is boneless dark-meat chicken cooked with ginger, garlic and cashew in a creamy sauce. The cashew gives the sauce its body, so it leans nutty rather than tomato-based.

The cashew also matters for allergies. Anyone with a tree-nut allergy should skip the Korma; the menu lists cashew in it, and the Vegetable Korma is described with cashew powder as well. For questions about other dishes, ask the kitchen when you order.

Order the Chicken Korma (GF) if:

  • You like a nutty, creamy sauce more than a tomato-based one.
  • No one at the table has a nut allergy.
  • You want a second GF-tagged curry next to the Butter Chicken.

Menu card — Chicken Korma (GF)

Boneless chicken (dark meat) cooked in ginger, garlic and cashew with a creamy sauce. Marked GF on the menu.

Order on the New Kathmandu Kitchen menu →

Which one is the mildest?

The ordering page doesn’t rank its curries by heat, so the honest answer is to ask the kitchen when you order. What the menu does tell you: the spicy label sits on the vindaloo dishes, not on these three, and the Chicken Saag (GF) is the one chicken curry the menu itself calls mildly spiced, cooked in a creamy spinach sauce. If the person you are ordering for is very careful about heat, that is worth a look too.

What to order with it

A creamy curry needs something to soak up the sauce. The menu gives you a few easy options:

  • Garlic Naan or Plain Naan/Butter Naan for scooping, or the Assorted Bread Basket (plain, garlic and onion naan, three in total) for a table.
  • Basmati Rice, which the menu describes as steamed aged basmati rice.
  • Raita, yogurt with chopped cucumber, carrot, cilantro and roasted ground cumin.
  • Mango Lassi, the homemade yogurt drink with mango, or Masala Chai.
  • Kheer for dessert, the chilled rice pudding with green cardamom, rosewater and a touch of cinnamon.

If you would rather order one plate that has everything on it, the menu’s combos are worth a look; the restaurant’s guide to choosing a thali explains the Non Veg, Vegetarian and Vegan options.

Ordering for two, four or the office

For two: pick two different curries, for example Butter Chicken and Chicken Tikka Masala, then share one rice and one naan. You get to compare the dark-meat and white-meat versions in one meal.

For four: order all three curries, two rice, the Assorted Bread Basket and a Raita. Everyone can try each sauce and settle on a favorite.

For an office lunch or a larger group: the catering page offers buffet setups and individual box lunches, with a free quote form and the phone number (916) 942-9796. It says the menu has extensive gluten-free and vegetarian options, which helps when you are feeding a mixed team.

FAQ

Q: What is the difference between butter chicken and chicken tikka masala?

A: At New Kathmandu Kitchen, Butter Chicken is tandoori dark-meat chicken in a thick buttery masala sauce, while Chicken Tikka Masala is white-meat chicken in a creamy onion-tomato masala sauce.

Q: Which Indian curry is the mildest?

A: The menu doesn’t rank its curries by heat, so ask the kitchen when you order. None of these three carries the spicy label, and the menu calls the Chicken Saag (GF) mildly spiced.

Q: Is butter chicken gluten free?

A: The Butter Chicken at New Kathmandu Kitchen carries the GF tag on the ordering page, and so does the Chicken Korma. The Chicken Tikka Masala does not, so ask the kitchen about it.

Q: What goes with chicken korma?

A: Basmati Rice or a naan for the sauce, and Raita on the side. The Korma contains cashew, so skip it for anyone with a nut allergy.

Q: Can I order Indian curry for delivery in East Sacramento?

A: Order through the restaurant’s own ordering page and check the pickup and delivery options at checkout. For large groups, use the catering page or call (916) 942-9796.

Order your curry night

Pick your curry, add rice and naan, and order from New Kathmandu Kitchen’s own ordering page, where the restaurant keeps the full order with no app commission. If you order often, the ordering page also runs a rewards program that earns points on direct orders.

Order direct from New Kathmandu Kitchen for pickup or delivery · For office and large orders, use the catering page.

Related Posts